Letter to Bowen on Nauru

Tags

,

Letter sent to Bowen NOV 13 2012

Recently, I have come back after doing humanitarian work with asylum seekers in the offshore processing centre in Nauru.  I have found it exceptionally difficult to express the frustration that I feel over the conditions that these men are suffering through, their lack of knowledge about their processing, and the effect that this has on their mental and physical health.  Although I am under confidentiality agreement, and do not want to breech that, my capped voice still needs to be heard, and there is much that I believe you need to hear.

This letter outlines some of my experiences and concerns, and draws upon the voices of the men in Nauru through the social sites that they have set up on wordpress.com and facebook.

These are the words from asylum seekers currently on Nauru;

“We have tolerated bad condition to reach Australia so as to save our lives and families.  On Wednesday two of the asylum seekers attempt suicide but fortunately being saved.  This was as sorrowfull events that no one remains without crying, weaping and protesting for their rights (3rd Nov, 2012).”

Imagine trying to sleep in a tent in heat and humidity that makes you sweat by just standing still.

“in Modern Period nobody wanna like keep even domestic animal in a tent at 42 Celsius temperature for a months, but the Human being are still living in in hell hole Nauru.”

I know that you have been to Nauru, and therefore have a sense of how hot and humid the temperature is. The campsite also floods when there is enough rain, and there is little space for recreational activities.  The men constantly ask when the buildings are going to be ready, when they are being built, where they are being built, and my response was always “I don’t know, I hope it will be soon. Things are changing.”

The reality is starker when I know that my Government will probably not invest in long-term infrastructure, when to my knowledge the contract has not been signed for houses to be built, and that houses might never be built.

This is a dumping ground for Australia’s unwanted, for those we wish to make an example of, for those who we want voiceless, off-shore where we are free of full responsibility, and it doesn’t matter that they might stay there for up to six years as PM Gillard has indicated, they will have to do that in tents.

I do not know how this demonstrates the Government’s new policy of ‘no-advantage.’  To me it demonstrates no regard for the Universal Declaration of Human Rights Convention, that people have the right to seek asylum in Australia. It shows no regard for the life of human beings.

The asylum seekers struggle to understand why they are being treated this way.  I struggle to understand why the Government believes that it is justifiable to treat people this way.

Furthermore, most of the men that are in Nauru, while I was there, were still on boats when the policy changed.  Deterrence cannot work without knowledge.  This is made even worse when the men are told one thing on Christmas Island, and come to Nauru and realise that this is not the case.  You should probably know, given your role, what information the asylum seekers received on Christmas Island regarding their freedom of movement and what DIAC have then told them in Nauru.  In not wanting to say anything that breeches my confidentiality agreement, I believe that this needs to be sorted out.  Even if this has changed, since I have been there, deterrence cannot work without knowledge, and many of the countries where asylum seekers are coming from are not giving that knowledge.  In my opinion, regional processing centres need to be opened in neighbouring countries such as Indonesia, and Malaysia BEFORE these men get onto boats, otherwise Nauru and Manus are just band-aid solutions.

Men have told me, that their lives are over and that all they think about are their families.  They have told me about all the precious things they are giving up to get to Australia, and it brings them to tears when they know that they are trapped in Nauru for an indefinite amount of time, being unable to return home or move forward, and leaving their families defenceless.

The men there have no idea how they are being processed.  It is Australia’s responsibility to address this and be clear and truthful to the men and the Australian public, seeing as these men sought asylum in Australia.  The men feel that

“now they have been to confined the prison like Nauru Hell for unknown time.  Day by day our mental and physical health is drawning bad and are attemptiing suicide and hunger strikes for unlimited time untill gettting our rights means taking us to Australia and processing our cases.”

As I write this, about 300 asylum seekers are on hunger strike in Nauru.  Change shouldn’t happen with the death of the first asylum seeker.  Change should start happening now.  This is a lot to ask, but this is what I am asking for:

  • A clear and truthful explanation to the asylum seekers on when and how they will be processed.  There is no reason why this processing should not happen within 6 months.
  • That the reasonable accommodations you have determined for these men in terms of resources and accommodation are made a whole lot more human and sustainable for the men in terms of their mental and physical health.
  • That the men are provided with a way to provide for their families.
  • That Nauru and Manus do not remain band-aid solutions, and that Australia works towards more serious ways of addressing the unsafe movement on people in our region.  Nauru and Manus are band-aid solutions not permanent and effective solutions.

I had the opportunity to start English lessons with these men.  We named the school Obweiy, which means Hope in Nauruan.  The men helped me move tables to make a makeshift classroom, were worried about me when I didn’t join them at lunch immediately after classes, brought me water, laughed at my interpretations of explaining the concept of dirty and pretending to be a washing machine, taught me phrases in their language, sang to me and with me, called me teacher and friend, and one my last day of teaching, each man shock my hand and thanked me for teaching them.  I have so much hope for the men there, that they will find the freedom they are looking for, and so much heartbreak at the way that they are being treated by a Government that we have democratically elected.  And I cry when I hear that the conditions will be worse on Manus, where we are sending families and unaccompanied minors.

Thank you for taking the time to hear my voice, capped as it is.

What really happened with that “Old disco hit”

Tags

, , ,

The media in Nauru were a set of impressive and determined people.  They somehow managed to climb the rocky outcrops surrounding the offshore processing centre, jumping across gaps that expanded 3 meters across at times in order to get a photograph of the camp even from a distance.  Hats off to you guys.

However, media are still media…painting a verbally aesthetic picture of a situation, and often missing the real beauty of the situation.

My co-teacher and another Salvation Army officer were given the opportunity to be interviewed by the Sydney Morning Herald.  The next day the article “Old disco hit strikes a poignant note for Nauru asylum seekers” was released saying…

FEW would have heard it, but on a recent balmy night in the hilly centre of Nauru, the tune of Gloria Gaynor’s ’70s disco hit “I Will Survive” was drifting on the Pacific breeze.

The camp in located on topside – there is no pacific breeze up there!  I’m also not entirely sure how in tune the singing was… Theatrical interpretation by a group of enthusiastic young Salvo’s crew is probably a more accurate description of what occurred.  It was also day time, but who ever cares about the particulars.

Given it was coming from the first offshore immigration camp built under the Gillard government’s reinvigoration of the Howard-era ”Pacific solution”, and was being sung by asylum seekers, it was not without irony.

And that song – being taught to asylum seekers by the Salvation Army as a way to improve their English – is only one small part of the daily existence of the would-be refugees on Nauru, revealed for the first time by a group of Salvation Army workers.

Such songs, picked from the top of our minds where interspersed between the most beautiful Tamil songs of sadness and love, that were rhythmically strummed out with hands, feet, and sticks.

We were certainly not teaching the asylum seekers how to survive (or how to sing the song), they have survived much more than we could ever imagine.  Instead we ourselves where being shown the strength of human determination, joy despite a desperate situation, and a sense of community, as the group encouraged each other through cheers, incredible dancing, and laughter.  Even the security guards joined in the merriment for a while.

People are incredible, that is what those moments show.  People are incredible.

Overall, the article was true to what both Paul and Tara said (except that the men get phone cards, not mobile phones, again the particulars), and gave a generally positive account of what The Salvation Army are achieving and aiming to achieve in the camp.  The Salvo’s are doing great things, but as Paul Moulds said.

”Is it how we would love it to be, today? Absolutely not,” Major Moulds said. ”But I can tell you, daily, things are being transformed.”

Every day I was there in Nauru the camp was transforming, and changing through the hard work of the Australian Army, the Salvation Army team, and frequently with the guidance of the asylum seekers.  I pray that things will be transformed all the more quickly for those already in Nauru, and those to follow.

Nauru: A place of heat, coral, and dogs.

Tags

, ,

It is difficult to know what to say, and how to say it, when you have signed a confidentiality agreement saying that you will not talk about what you have heard and seen inside the offshore processing centre in Nauru.  It is difficult to express your feelings and emotions when you have created relationships with the men in the camp who are very real and loving, and all you want for them is that they find the freedom they are looking for.  It is difficult.

Over the next few blogs, I will try to express some of the things that I have seen and felt without breaking that confidentiality agreement.

What can I say?  Nauru is hot and humid.  Imagine trying to sleep in a tent in heat and humidity that makes you sweat by just standing still.  When it does rain, and there is a breeze, there are small moments of respite from the heat.  Then the rain stops and you are hit by the heat doubly from heat steaming off the ground.  If there is no breeze, your own sweat does not even cool you down, and you sport a stunning sweat moustache.  There were times when I would step off a bus and somewhat comically, my glasses would fog up.  Nauru is hot. Continue reading →

Emails, contacts, and stress levels

Currently, most people in our honours cohort are stressing about meeting up with their honours supervisor, doing the assessments, plagiarism, doing and finding readings, and the general writing of the literature review. Or, preparing for the report that I am presenting on Wednesday…

I feel like those are the things that I should be stressing about, but am not.  The bane of my honours existence at present, is something that should seem second nature to those of us living in and amongst new technologies, and even a bit archaic; sending emails.

I am so thankful to those contacts that I had before pursuing honours, and am so thankful that they have led me to finding other contacts, and then to more.  So thankful that people have sent me readings, and have been happy to answer questions, and give me contact details, and send me to relevant sites and places.

But, I spend an hour trying to compose the perfect email to initiate contact.  I get someone to check every sentence, and scrutinise about the connotations attached to every word.  And…finally send. Only to copy and paste everything into a word document, with the date, and copy and paste all further correspondence with the date.  Thank goodness I stopped doing that, a bit creepy, and way too much effort considering I can see all of that by opening an email.

And then, after formally introducing myself through email, and sending the right amount of information, and stressing about the whole process.  I get a response (in most cases), only to then stress about sending my response within the same time limit. Or trying to remember who you have emailed with what, and who has gotten back to you with what.

And stress about not sounding too desperate.

PLEASE LET ME COME AND … AND INTERVIEW … AND ANSWER … AND SEND ME THE DETAILS …

The worst thing is not having anything to offer in return.

So far, the best contact have been made through people that I have an established relationship with.  They have all been so willing to help, which has been encouraging.  The hardest contacts have been those that I have no connection with whatsoever.

The most exciting thing about making contact with people I don’t know is that when I get to Cambodia (God willing!) I will be able to meet and thank these people in person, and hopefully get a greater understanding of their lives and the work they do in Cambodia.

Even when I am stressed, and worried about all the emails I need to send, I think I need to remember that these people are offering me a gift that they don’t need to, and I need to be thankful of that.

Discovering that foundational piece! Ecstatic!

There is this amazing reading I found for honours!  That at first glance incorporates all the aspects of awesomeness that I have been searching for, and could be pivotal to my literature review.  It was seriously love at first sight, the title, the extract, the references.  The fact that they weren’t paid by the government or a non-government to write the research.

I even read their Bio’s.  As if I was a star struck teen.

But, I am too excited, and nervous to read it.  Excited because it gives me a very good framework in which to write my honours thesis, nervous because it seems to be doing exactly what I was planning on doing and discovering.  Which means I now have to dig deeper, or write a cover song.

I am currently three pages into the research, and already two pages of that is highlighted.  Compare this to listening to the first song of an album on repeat, without being able to listen to the rest.

After that, I got so excited that I had to go tell everyone else how excited I was.  This is a strange phenomena.  Who gets this excited about an academic piece of literature.  It must mean that I actually care about what I am researching; awesome!

I might have to get someone to read the rest of the article out loud to me.  Or, take little bites of it over several days, ensuring that I have enough water and loose clothing to avoid over excitement and dehydration, and eventual collapse.

Look forward to it!

Disability and Human Rights: Mercer and MacDonald’s Foresight

Tags

, , , ,

People have been working towards Human Rights for those with Disabilities for a long time.  However, the process has been slow, and it interesting to note that Mercer and MacDonald in their article Disability and Human Rights (2007) picked up on important issues which might have, and have affected the inclusion of those with disabilities in the ‘Global South.’

The UN Convention of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, according to Mercer and MacDonald have marked a ‘paradigm shift’ and a step forward for those with disabilities, as the Convention demonstrated the possibility of integrating disability into mainstream issues. Although the article by Mercer and MacDonald was written in 2007, it is interesting to note how they picked up on important issues that it has taken ‘the mainstream’ a while to to take action on.

MacDonald and Mercer note that currently (both in 2007, and even now) countries such as Cambodia heavily rely on non-government organisations to assist those with disabilities, as there is little governmental assistance.  Due to this they argue,

failure to make disability a key policy issue in the recovery and development of countries such as Cambodia is perhaps not only the fault of the individual governments.

Although they do not expand on their argument entirely, and I believe that it can be taken in several ways, although all of them can be true to an extent.

1. Governments have no incentive to make disability a key policy due to their reliance and expectations on Non-Goverments to do the work for them?
2. Non-Goverments have not made disability a priority
3. The Global World has not made disability a priority.

Mercer and MacDonald illustrate that disability is not included in the Millennium Development Goals at all…

Now as we have increasingly seen and know the Millennium Development Goals, cannot and will not be reached without taking into account and addressing the needs of those with disabilities.

Mercer and MacDonald argued that a fundamental shift in how we view disability and how we fund and focus the fight against global poverty needs to occur.  Although I feel that, particularly in the past few years disability has moved more to the forefront of Non-governments and donar-governments agenda, is it really the priority it needs to be?

On a positive! There is definitely great work being done out there (for example CBM), and an increasing amount of research, but it is just interesting how this article in particular with foresight, has highlighted problems that research I am reading now points back to.

Mercer, S. W., & MacDonald, R. (2007). Disability and human rights. The Lancet, 548-549.

Modelling and Scaffolding Essays

Tags

, , ,

One of the teachers in the staff room sent me the site “writing and exposition, laptop wraps.”  It’s an online based source to assist students with their exposition writing. Expositions can include speeches, blogs, essays, and other persuasive pieces of writing.

The site includes a series of activities and scaffolds.  The scaffold I thought would be particularly useful for teaching is a web-based Essay Map from ReadWriteThink. This could be used across any subject area as the basis for writing an introduction/ thesis/ argument, then coming up with three key points, giving evidence for these, and making a concluding statement.  Below is a brief example of how the site is structured. Students can also save or email the essay maps to themselves or the teacher.  Meaning that the teacher can monitor and give feedback to essay outlines.

The teacher could model the planning process of using the Essay Map, before getting students to write their own.  Teachers could also scaffold this activity, by getting students to brain-storm ideas before starting the writing process.  After the students have completed the Essay Map, they can start writing their introduction and paragraphs, and then publish them on a class site such as edmodo.

Bubbl.us and getting more descriptive with Crime Writing

Tags

, , ,

Bubbl.us is an online brainstorming tool.  Students visually map from a central concepts, expand upon these concepts, and can demonstrate linkages between concepts.  Bubbl.us is useful for class discussions and activities as teachers can save the map, and distribute it to all students.

Teachers can scaffold student understanding of crime fiction genres, by visually mind mapping the main elements of the genre; an example is given above.  Students can then use the elements of the genre to write creative pieces.  Furthermore, students can brainstorm their own creative writing pieces before starting the writing process.  Bubbl.us is particularly useful for students to scaffold the linkages between characters, plot points, red herrings, and clues.

If students have an understanding of the genre, but their creative writing pieces are lacking in authenticity, and descriptiveness, Bubbl.us can be used for the following activity.  The teacher or class selects a certain character, or setting.  Students brainstorm descriptions of this character or setting on Bubbl.us.  When sufficient responses have been given, the teacher informs students that they are to write a descriptive paragraph about this character or setting without using any of the brainstormed words, or deviations thereof.  This activity aims to encourage students to write more descriptively, and creatively, and encourages students to think deeper about settings and characters.

Feel free to comment or like this blog if you found it interesting or useful!

A similar activity can be found on for getting students more descriptive in general. https://catswhiteboard.wordpress.com/2011/10/29/355/

Prezi, Flickr, and Creative Crime Writing

Tags

, , , ,

Prezi is a web-based resource that allows students and teachers to create presentations that can be more engaging and interactive than a standard powerpoint.  Prezi allows teachers to incorporate visuals, film, and text and show links between textual information.

Flickr is another web-based resource where individuals, groups, museums, and libraries upload and share photos for other individuals to access.  Students and teachers can draw upon ‘The Commons’ and ‘Creative Commons’ adhering to respective copyright licenses.  Flickr allows teachers and students to find relevant, quality photographs that relate to the settings, characters, and time periods (for example the images included) for creative pieces. Above is an image from Flickr that you could use in relation to crime fiction.

Teachers can create a Prezi with images from Flickr and crime fiction related quotations.  Students are given a certain amount of planning time and writing time on each piece of stimulus.  Time can be automated on Prezi, which gives the teacher greater flexibility to walk around the classroom.  Shorter writing circuits are particularly useful when students struggle initiating with the writing process, as students work to write as much as possible within a certain time limit.  This also encourages students to prepare for the HSC creative writing stimulus in an engaging manner.

Students can also use Prezi and Flickr to visually design story and idea boards for their creative pieces.  Students can use pictures of relevant settings that they are trying to describe, gather visual resources for time periods and the crime fiction genre, for example film noir; and visually demonstrate the links between plot points.  This scaffolds student’s learning, allows teachers to formatively assess, and provides students alternative means to demonstrate their understanding.

Feel free to comment or like this blog if you found it interesting or useful!

Continue reading →

Drama and Introducing Crime Writing

Tags

, , , , , ,

The following are some engaging ways to introduce students into crime writing and the conventions of crime writing.

Death in 30 seconds

In groups of three students either improvise or plan a death in 30 seconds.  Other students play the detective and figure out whether the death was natural or murder, and what evidence could be used to decide.  Depending on the class, scenario cards can be given to groups to scaffold the activity.

Crime Fiction Space Jumps

Space jump is a drama improvisation game, where a student is given a scene or scenario that they act out in a set time limit.  When ‘Space Jump” is called out, the student freezes, and another student needs to create another scenario based of the frozen position of the first student.

The teacher can theme these space jumps to suit crime fiction and give introductory prompts, for example “murder in the morgue” or “following suspect of money laundering.”  After students have had a general introduction to crime fiction genres and subgenres, students can be given different sub-genres of crime fiction that they jump into, for example noir or cosy.

Reflection and connection to learning

After these activities, students can discuss their roles as detectives, victims, and witnesses of crime through role-play.  Students can also discuss what conventions they drew upon in order to make obvious the crime fiction genre, or subgenres they were portraying.

Feel free to comment or like this blog if you found it interesting or useful!
Continue reading →

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free